"Have your say"

This discussion is in: Should the date for Who Do We Think We Are? Week be changed in future years? > Tell us what you think?

Tell us what you think?

Post Comment
J Smith
Monday 5th May 2008 12:28
Tell us what you think:
  • Should Who Do We Think We Are? Week be linked to St George's Day in future years, or should it be fixed to coincide with Olympic Day?
  • Are there any other dates that should be considered, so that Who Do We Think We Are? Week occurs at a completely different time in the school year?
  • Should Who Do We Think We Are? Week be linked to a specific date in the cultural calendar - such as Holocaust Memorial Day, or Black History Month?




6 Responses to Tell us what you think?
1
frances francis
Saturday 24th May 2008 18:38
'Who do we think we are' should not be designated to a particular week because that would be quite unfair. The diverse cultural identity of Britain cannot be pegged to a particular date. Finding our past and our origins should be an ongoing feature of learning as it will engage pupils and carers to look more closely at their own history in the broader context of world history. A word of warning, finding out about your past hurts. Somewhere in your past, a relative may have been treated extremely unfairly and this will impact on your own feelings and sense of belonging. Social injustice has also occurred to Catholics as well as Jews and people born in other countries or other cultures.

2
frances francis
Sunday 1st June 2008 15:46
After researching my own family past, contacting and meeting relatives I had never met before at a large family gathering of over a hundred people, I can say it was worth the effort. Our family has got together because of one particular ancestor who was hidden in Coventry, brought up by a childminder, sold as an apprentice to the ribbon mill at the age of 16, forgotten by her real parents, married a shoemaker and had 14 children, died in the workhouse and buried in an unmarked grave. As a result of the family gathering we are going to buy a gravestone for our ancestor to lend a little dignity to her terrible ending.

3
Kate Manning
Friday 13th June 2008 12:52
WDWTWA week occurs at the end of June, which has this year been designated as Gypsy Roma Traveller History Month. There is clearly a tie in between the two. Here in Essex we are holding an Open Day at our Traveller Education Resource Centre btween 10 and 3 on Wednesday 25 June. The centre is in Braintree at the Alec Hunter Humanities College. CM7 3NT. All welcome, please contact me for travel directions.

4
Barbara Hibbert
Tuesday 17th June 2008 19:02
I think a week early in the new academic year would be a good time to focus on WDWTWA as a way of introducing new students in secondary schools to some key issues for the next stage of their education.

5
Iftikhar Ahmad
Thursday 19th June 2008 21:53
Muslim Ghettoisation: "We live in a shrunken world and millions of people are on the move; one of our biggest challenges is how we learn to live in proximity to difference – different skin colours, different beliefs and different way of life. According to a study by COMPAS, Muslims born and educated were given the impression of outsiders. The perception among Muslims that they are unwelcome in Britain is undermining efforts to help them integrate into wider society. Most of them say that they have experienced race discrimination and religious prejudice. Muslims and Islam are promoted as fundamentalist and separatist by the western elite, which have a negative impact on community and social cohesion. The number of racist incidents occurring in the London Borough of Redbridge’s schools have reached their highest levels since records began. A City or a locality, where Muslims are in majority is a ghetto. There is a tendency for people of similar backgrounds to live together in neighourhoods. The term”ghettoisation” is inappropriate. The original ghettos in Europe during the middle ages were set up by law to confine the Jewish population to one area of a city. According to research by an Australian academic Muslim communities in Britain are being increasingly ghettoized in a trend that sets back hopes of assimilation by years. Britain has now eight cities in the top 100 most ghettoized cities. The people from the Pakistani community in Bradford and Oldham and Leicester had trebled during the decade. A report by an academic Dr Alan Carling stated that Bradford risks becoming a front line in the global clash between the West and Islam. But Islam and Muslims do not clash with the concepts of pluralism, secularism and globalisation. The native flight from Bradford’s inner-city wards showed clear evidence of an increase in segregation in the city since 1991. Native parents are avoiding sending their children in state schools where Muslims and other minorities are in the majority. The dominance of Pakistani Muslims in the city has meant that Bradford has become bi-cultural. Immigrants are the creators of Britain new wealth, otherwise, inner cities deprived areas could not get new lease of life. The native Brits regard such areas as ghettoes. Integration is not religious and cultural, it is economic and Muslims are well integrated into British society and at the same time they are proud of their Islamic, linguistic and cultural identities, inspite of discrimination they have been facing in all walks of life. According to UN, 80% of British Muslims feel discriminated. They are less burden on social services. Immigrants made up 8.7% of the population, but accounted for10.2% of all collected income tax It is often quoted by the Western media that Muslim schools ghettoizse the children, and even lead to their radicalisation if they are not integrated. There is no evidence that faith schools lead to a “ghettoized education system. In British schools, pupils are encouraged to focus too much on their similarities rather than their differences. The integrationist approach merely results in Muslims feeling that their faith, language and culture is not respected." Written by Iftikhar Ahmad London School of Islamics, 63 Margery Park Road, London E7 9LD. The london School of Islamics is an Educational Trust, Established in 1981. Email: info@londonschoolofislamics.org.uk Website: www.londonschoolofislamics.org.uk Tel/Fax: 0208 555 2733 / 07817 112 667 Submitted in response to Sir Keith Ajegbo's article titled 'These days people are on the move" http://www.wdwtwa.org.uk/news/55/these-days-people-are-on-the-move.html DISCLAIMER The views and opinions expressed in the commentary featured above are the writer's own and do not represent the views of either the Who Do We Think We Are (WDWTWA) consortium of partners (Royal Geographical Society with IBG, the Historical Association and Citizenship Consultant Paula Kitching) or the project's funding body, the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF). If you would like to comment on the content of this article, please send a response via the WDWTWA Blog (Have your say) or email the Project Coordinator, c/o C.Dixon@rgs.org.

6
Pierre Schramm
Tuesday 24th June 2008 10:40
Why St George's Day? From what I could gather, this is an initiative to think about what Britishness in general is, and more particularly about personal identity. St George is the patron of England, not Britain, and hardly represents anything that would be considered typically British. If any specific date should be considered, I reckon Guy Fawkes Day would be better suited. Any other candidates for a date I can think of (EU treaties, royalty-related dates, ...) would express a political stance, which I am not sure WDWTWA wants.

Post Your Comments
1. Your details and your comment (Name and Comment are required)
Name: (Required)

Email: (Optional)

Comment: (Required)
2. Media (Image, Audio or Video), Attachments and Links (Optional)
Media (Image, Audio or Video): (Optional)

Attachment (Documents e.g. Word or PDF): (Optional)

Links: (Optional)
Title will be displayed e.g. "Who Do We Think We Are Website", URL is the address e.g. "http://www.wdwtwa.org.uk/"

Link Title:     URL:
Link Title:     URL:
3. Security (Required)
Security Code: (Required)
Enter the code you can see in the box